CMXtraneous: Education

Right on the edge of useful

The Days of Whine and Browser Sniffing ...

Posted Wednesday, May 11, 2005 2:38:59 PM by Stephanie

Stephanie

I really thought we were done with this. At least I thought that larger, more professional sites had changed. Browser sniffing. Locking people out of web sites due to their browser choice. What happened to presenting an unstyled page to those who choose a more current browser? What about screen readers?

Case in point -- National Geographic. As some of you know, I home school my sons. This morning, I was helping the eldest with some Grasslands research for Biology class. I Googled what appeared to be a great link. However, when I hit it, this is what I got:

Your Browser is not supported

The Following Browsers are supported:
Please download one of these free browsers and try again.

Netscape 4
Netscape 6
Internet Explorer 4
Internet Explorer 5
Internet Explorer 5.5
Internet Explorer 6

So rather than telling me my experience would be better if I were using one of these icky browsers, they choose to completely lock me out. Ahhh, but I'm one of those smart web developer types, right? So I just go to my little Web Developer's Toolbar, and I turn off JavaScript. They can't sniff without it! Now I'm all set to read. I refresh my page and voila! I have nothing. I have a completely and totally white page. Okay...

Final ditch effort. View Source. Wow -- the whole, entire, freaking page is loaded with JavaScript. There is no page without it. So they sniff and then they load. If they can't sniff, they don't load anything.

Yes, I have access to a PC. And yes, I went to the page and know that the main portion is an "interactive" map -- albeit a very slow clunky one. I wonder if they actually tested it in Moz-based browsers before they locked everyone except IE and NN out. Perhaps, they could allow the rest of the page to load? Maybe I'd like to see and use the sidebars, even if they've created something in the main area that no browser but IE and NN can handle? That would be swell.

Category tags: Accessibility, Dreamweaver, Education, JavaScript, Mac